Browse: Home / Not Just Because I Like the Clothes

Menu

Skip to content
  • Home
  • Who We Are
  • About
  • Privacy
  • Contact Us
  • Login

The-SoluteLogo

A Film Site By Lovers of Film

Menu

Skip to content
  • Features
  • Reviews
  • Long Reviews
  • News
  • Articles and Opinions
  • Other Media
  • New on DVD and Blu-Ray
  • Local 32-Year-Old Man Successfully Expands His Taste In Music
  • Celebrating the Living: Kirk R. Thatcher
  • Attention Must Be Paid: Whitney Blake
  • Disney Byways: Non-Disney Properties on Disney+

Not Just Because I Like the Clothes

Posted By Gillianren on July 22, 2015 in Short Articles | 19 Responses

It should have come as no surprise to me that The Rocketeer and Captain America: The First Avenger were directed by the same person. I spotted the similarities in the theater—I actually saw both of them in the theatre. Joe Johnston has not, I have to say, had the greatest career. He’s directed a whopping ten movies, including Jurassic Park III and Honey, I Shrunk the Kids. However, if you look at his actually good movies, or even his mediocre ones with a better visual style, what they have in common is that they are all period pieces.

I love a good period piece. There are some stories that are just better told in an older time. For our first two examples, let us consider the worlds these characters inhabit, because they’re both good examples of when the period piece works best. Then, we’ll talk about a few proposed remakes that, if we must have them, we should make as they ought to be done, not modernized.

The Rocketeer didn’t just need to be a period piece because Howard Hughes invented the rocket. I mean, for all it really matters to the plot, Tony Stark could have invented the rocket. That’s not the point. There are a few other things that do matter. I must admit that one of them is the visual aesthetic; the Rocketeer just works best in Art Deco. For the plot, though, an important consideration is the political feel of the times. Without Nazis, the Rocketeer is just another superhero. Not even a particularly good one, if we are being honest. He’s got a jet pack, but he needs a gun and isn’t particularly strong or bulletproof or agile or anything. He’s not a great detective. But he’s an All-American Boy who can strap a jet onto his back and fight Nazis, and that only works if you stick him in the mid ’30s. Any other era and any other villain, it’s frankly kind of dumb.

As for Cap, well, the creation of Captain America in-universe also pretty well relies on the Nazis. It has to be long enough ago, for example, that you don’t have a lot of pesky review boards telling you that you can’t use untried serum on human subjects. Spider-Man dodges that by having Norman Osborne use the stuff on himself, but it’s the reason The Experiment, a 2010 movie about the Stanford Prison Experiment fails. (Or one of them, anyway; it’s not a very good movie on several levels.) They didn’t make it a period piece, and all you can think is, “How did they get away with doing this experiment?” With Cap, you know they got away with it because it was the ’40s, and a patriotic boy would do just about anything to help fight the Nazis.

I have, over the years, seen plenty of movies that would have worked better as period pieces, often because the plot relied on attitudes that were anachronistic or events that go against one established practice or another but wouldn’t in another era. It somehow doesn’t work when all those classic books in movies made in the ’30s were still set in the ’30s; sometimes, a fantasy time that isn’t modern or period works, but more often, it’s just an awkward mess.

Now, I heard the other day that Robert Downey, Jr., is hoping to get a Perry Mason movie made. I have not only seen probably the entire series at one point or another, I have read quite a few of the books. I know a good deal about the character, and I’m hesitantly approving. Okay, so he’s too old—Perry is, in my opinion, probably in his late thirties or early forties, though I don’t think it ever says—but that doesn’t seem to matter if you’re a male actor. And, yes, a lot will depend on who they cast as Della, Paul, and so forth. However, I hear he does indeed plan to make it a period piece, and that’s great. There are nuances in the books that didn’t make it into the TV show because of when it was made. I believe they can now, and they’d be lost if you set them in a time when it didn’t matter if Della got married or not when it came to expectations about her career.

Similarly, I’ve heard vague noises about a remake of The Thin Man, and that simply wouldn’t work in a modern setting. How could Wynant completely disappear in this day and age? No hits on his credit cards? No appearance on social media? No being caught in someone else’s pictures? No, that doesn’t work. It’s a lot harder to drop completely out of touch now than it was in 1934. Even if you want to.

There are good and bad adaptations when it comes to choosing not to do the period piece. I actually happen to like the Baz Luhrmann Romeo + Juliet. On the other hand, you couldn’t do a modern reimagining of The Great Gatsby, and just sticking in a bunch of modern trappings isn’t at all the same thing. It still needs to be explicitly the Roaring Twenties in order for everything going on to hang together. It’s not a failing of a work to be better set in a specific period or admirable for being more universal, necessarily. It just makes them different. I admire when people making an adaptation know enough to know when something, yes, just needs to be set in a specific time and work within that framework.

Posted in Short Articles | Tagged captain america, period piece, the rocketeer

About the Author

gillianmadeira@hotmail.com'

Gillianren

Gillianren is a forty-something bipolar woman living in the Pacific Northwest after growing up in Los Angeles County. She and her boyfriend have one son and one daughter, and she gave a daughter up for adoption. She fills her days by watching her local library system’s DVD collection in alphabetical order, watching everything that looks interesting. She particularly enjoys pre-Code films, blaxploitation, and live-action Disney movies of the ’60s and ’70s. She has a Patreon account at https://www.patreon.com/gillianren

Related Posts

One of Kurosawa's best-filmed scenesKurosawa the Modern Master→

Yup, eating fruit with chopsticks--perfectly normalA Snapshot of an Era→

Hic Incipit Pestis→

Past Is Prestige→

  • Comments
  • Popular
  • Most Recent
  • j*****@yahoo.com'
    mr_apollo on Year of the Month: Mon OncleWonderful piece, Sam. It's made…
  • j*****@yahoo.com'
    mr_apollo on Year of the Month: Mon OncleFellow heretic here. I've never…
  • n***********@gmail.com'
    Ruck Cohlchez on Film on the Internet: AN AMERICAN CRIMEI wouldn't have called it…
  • j***********@gmail.com'
    Son of Griff on LIFE ITSELFGlad to hear back from…
  • n*********@gmail.com'
    Jake Gittes on Film on the Internet: AN AMERICAN CRIMEThis is the single most…
  • “The End” of SAVAGES

    33894 views / Posted November 10, 2014
  • What the fuck did I just watch? SPHERE

    27463 views / Posted March 19, 2015
  • The Untalented Mr. Ripley: The Craft of Standup Comedy and the Non-Comedy of TOM MYERS

    25090 views / Posted June 26, 2018
  • Scenic Routes: SHOWGIRLS (1995)

    20110 views / Posted November 20, 2014
  • Yvonne, or: CASABLANCA In One Character and Three Scenes

    11152 views / Posted August 21, 2014
  • New on DVD and Blu-Ray

    March 28, 2023 / Greta Taylor
  • Local 32-Year-Old Man Successfully Expands His Taste In Music

    March 27, 2023 / Tristan "Drunk Napoleon" Nankervis
  • Today, in "images you can hear"

    Celebrating the Living: Kirk R. Thatcher

    March 26, 2023 / Gillianren
  • Her second stint as Perry's defendant

    Attention Must Be Paid: Whitney Blake

    March 25, 2023 / Gillianren
  • My face on seeing the "recently added"

    Disney Byways: Non-Disney Properties on Disney+

    March 24, 2023 / Gillianren

Last Tweets

  • New on DVD and Blu-Ray - https://t.co/eTSlUOrMxP, 18 hours ago
  • Local 32-Year-Old Man Successfully Expands His Taste In Music - https://t.co/GoGCg4XoOK, Mar 27
  • Celebrating the Living: Kirk R. Thatcher - https://t.co/MmxFh9W4xf, Mar 26

©2014 - 2016 The-Solute | Hosted, Developed and Maintained by Bellingham WP LogoBellinghamWP.com.

Menu

  • Home
  • Who We Are
  • About
  • Privacy
  • Contact Us
  • Login
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!