Browse: Home / Shorter Can Be Better

Menu

Skip to content
  • Home
  • Who We Are
  • About
  • Privacy
  • Contact Us
  • Login

The-SoluteLogo

A Film Site By Lovers of Film

Menu

Skip to content
  • Features
  • Reviews
  • Long Reviews
  • News
  • Articles and Opinions
  • Other Media
  • Danny Devito’s Matilda Captured the Essence of Ronald Dahl Better Than Most Adaptations by James Williams
  • Exactly One Implausibility
  • Celebrating the Living: Barbara Ling
  • Attention Must Be Paid: Theodore Bikel
  • Disney Byways: "On Ice"

Shorter Can Be Better

Posted By Gillianren on December 16, 2020 in Short Articles | Leave a response

This is the season where we get some of the greatest half-hours of television ever made. High on that list is “How the Grinch Stole Christmas,” the original made-for-television half-hour short, directed by Chuck Jones. (Famously, Dr. Seuss said that the Grinch in it more resembles Jones that the book illustration, and he wasn’t wrong, but who cares?) It is a beautiful piece of television. Funny and adventurous and even suspenseful even though we’ve all seen it about eighty billion times in our lives. And then there’s the movie.

Yeah, yeah. A lot of people like the movie. But Seuss hasn’t done that well in feature adaptations. He and Stephen King could have a club. I’m sure we could add others to that list. And I think one of the things the ones with the longest list of bad adaptations would have in common is that the length of their fiction is wrong for the standard feature-length adaptation. That’s kind of one King gets coming and going—some of his work really needs the miniseries treatment. But the short stories should be short films.

It’s not really revolutionary, you wouldn’t think, and another strange intersection of Seuss and King is that they have indeed both had considerable success in television adaptations. Oh, yes, The Stand, but also the Nightmares and Dreamscapes collection, which was an assortment of adaptations of his short stories that was actually produced as a series of short films. Alas not “The Lawnmower Man,” the most notorious of his poor adaptations inasmuch as he literally sued to have his name taken off it.

Some short story adaptations are surprisingly good. Where the Wild Things Are is a bare handful of sentences long, and the movie is—in my opinion, at least—outstanding. Because it knew where to leave the book aside and go other places and it knew how to do that in a way that fit with the mood of the book. Which is a fine way of adapting a work regardless of how long or short your adaptation and your original work are, really, but Spike Jonze definitely did it to good effect there.

And you hear a lot that there aren’t a lot of places for short films, but that’s a lie now, isn’t it? I mean, it always has been, for the entire history of film. It’s just that places that could have shown great half-hour films or whatever weren’t inclined to air them, for the most part. But with streaming, there absolutely is no excuse. Why shouldn’t we have a half-hour “Cask of Amontillado” or “Masque of the Red Death” on Netflix instead of just the Corman ones that had nothing to do with the stories?

I can feel you all gearing up to tell me in the comments that there are some stone-cold classic films that started as short stories. Rear Window and Rashomon, just for starters, and you’re quite right. And goodness knows the live-action Cat in the Hat had problems beyond length, but I think at least one of the problems is that the book is so short that they decided they needed to pad it, and it was padded badly. Stagecoach comes from “The Stage to Lordsburg,” which is about twenty pages long. But it is twenty busy pages.

In short, the length of the adaptation should be what is best for the work. Just as The Hobbit didn’t need to be three movies, I can’t imagine that The Lorax is really better at 86 minutes than the 25 minutes of the made-for-TV version. Even that is, honestly, a bit padded. It’s just padded better and for less time. So it could be and demonstrably was worse.

Reward me for making you think of Stephen King and Dr. Seuss in the same context; consider supporting my Patreon or Ko-fi!

Posted in Short Articles | Tagged Adaptations

About the Author

gillianmadeira@hotmail.com'

Gillianren

Gillianren is a forty-something bipolar woman living in the Pacific Northwest after growing up in Los Angeles County. She and her boyfriend have one son and one daughter, and she gave a daughter up for adoption. She fills her days by watching her local library system’s DVD collection in alphabetical order, watching everything that looks interesting. She particularly enjoys pre-Code films, blaxploitation, and live-action Disney movies of the ’60s and ’70s. She has a Patreon account at https://www.patreon.com/gillianren

Related Posts

Enduring Faithfulness→

Film on the Internet: AN AMERICAN CRIME→

The Spiral: Avathoir and wallflower Talk About Thomas Pynchon, 9: INHERENT VICE (Also We Liveblog the Movie!)→

Dissolve On (10/15/2017-10/21/2017)→

  • Comments
  • Popular
  • Most Recent
  • j*****@yahoo.com'
    mr_apollo on Year of the Month: Mon OncleWonderful piece, Sam. It's made…
  • j*****@yahoo.com'
    mr_apollo on Year of the Month: Mon OncleFellow heretic here. I've never…
  • n***********@gmail.com'
    Ruck Cohlchez on Film on the Internet: AN AMERICAN CRIMEI wouldn't have called it…
  • j***********@gmail.com'
    Son of Griff on LIFE ITSELFGlad to hear back from…
  • n*********@gmail.com'
    Jake Gittes on Film on the Internet: AN AMERICAN CRIMEThis is the single most…
  • What the fuck did I just watch? SPHERE

    21516 views / Posted March 19, 2015
  • Scenic Routes: SHOWGIRLS (1995)

    16939 views / Posted November 20, 2014
  • “The End” of SAVAGES

    16828 views / Posted November 10, 2014
  • The Untalented Mr. Ripley: The Craft of Standup Comedy and the Non-Comedy of TOM MYERS

    11193 views / Posted June 26, 2018
  • B.O.O.: The DreamWorks Animation Movie You Will Never See

    7891 views / Posted January 28, 2016
  • Danny Devito’s Matilda Captured the Essence of Ronald Dahl Better Than Most Adaptations by James Williams

    January 25, 2021 / Sam "Burgundy Suit" Scott
  • Exactly One Implausibility

    January 25, 2021 / Tristan "Drunk Napoleon" Nankervis
  • Celebrating the Living: Barbara Ling

    January 24, 2021 / Gillianren
  • Attention Must Be Paid: Theodore Bikel

    January 23, 2021 / Gillianren
  • Disney Byways: “On Ice”

    January 22, 2021 / Gillianren

Last Tweets

  • Danny Devito’s Matilda Captured the Essence of Ronald Dahl Better Than Most Adaptations by James Williams - https://t.co/MbWSJXvcpw, 20 hours ago
  • Exactly One Implausibility - https://t.co/2pgrFXa7No, 20 hours ago
  • Celebrating the Living: Barbara Ling - https://t.co/TPwF7v5q3X, Jan 24

©2014 - 2016 The-Solute | Hosted, Developed and Maintained by Bellingham WP LogoBellinghamWP.com.

Menu

  • Home
  • Who We Are
  • About
  • Privacy
  • Contact Us
  • Login
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!